Interface

Between Heaven and Earth

The Scandalous Teachings of Jesus 4: Let the Dead Bury Their Dead?

In life, some responsibilities cannot wait. If a parent dies, we stop what we are doing and go home. We take care of the funeral, comfort our family, and make sure the person we love is laid to rest with dignity. We would not call that a distraction. We would call it love.

So why does Jesus tell a man who wants to bury his father, “Let the dead bury their own dead”? Jesus then tells him to go and preach about God’s Kingdom. The saying is difficult. This man’s request is reasonable and, in some sense, even sacred. 

For the past three weeks, we have been looking at teachings of Jesus that unsettle us. Today we are looking at Luke 9:57-62. 

Luke 9: 57-62 As they were going along the road, someone said to him, “I will follow you wherever you go.”And Jesus said to him, “Foxes have holes, and birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.” To another he said, “Follow me.” But he said, “Lord, first let me go and bury my father.” And Jesus said to him, “Let the dead bury their own dead, but as for you, go and proclaim the kingdom of God.”Another said, “I will follow you, Lord, but let me first say farewell to those at my home.” And Jesus said to him, “No one who puts a hand to the plow and looks back is fit for the kingdom of God.”

Three people encounter Jesus on the road. The first promises to follow Him wherever He goes. The second is called to follow, but asks to bury his father first. The third agrees to follow, but wants to say goodbye to his family first. Each response raises the same question: What comes first when following Jesus?

Luke places this story right at the start of Jesus’s journey to Jerusalem. A Samaritan village refuses to welcome Jesus, so James and John want to call down fire on it. Jesus rebukes them, and the group moves on. Next, Luke introduces three encounters with potential followers. Jesus is walking straight toward Jerusalem, where he will face rejection and death, while sending others out to announce God’s Kingdom. That looming journey fills the whole story with urgency, even though Luke never tells us the exact details about the man’s father.

We do not know whether the father is already dead. We do not know whether the man means the immediate funeral or some later burial practice. We do not know how long he wants to wait. Biblical scholars have offered several possible explanations.

What does Jesus mean when he says, “Let the dead bury their own dead”? How can a dead person bury someone else? For clarity, some Bible translations add the word “spiritually” before the first “dead.” In other words, Jesus is saying: “Let those who are spiritually dead, those who have not responded to God’s Kingdom, bury the physically dead. As for you, who have accepted me, go and proclaim the Kingdom.” This explains the wordplay.

This raises two obvious questions: First, why is this man traveling with Jesus if his father has just died and needs a burial? Second, is Jesus really saying that everyone outside his movement is spiritually dead?

Some scholars point out that Jesus is creating a new kind of family centered on his mission, and he is asking this man to prioritize that new community over his biological family. 

We have to tread carefully here. Labeling people outside the group as “dead” carries a real risk: it can dehumanize others and make great harm feel justified. We see this pattern clearly throughout history. From the religious wars of Europe to the Crusades, language that divides people into the spiritually living and dead can be used to justify exclusion or violence. Biblical scholar Crispin Fletcher-Louis argues that Jesus separates his followers from their old family ties, while making clear that this separation has nothing to do with violent practices that denied people a proper burial.

When we look closely at why Jesus said, “Let the dead bury the dead,” people who study the text have a few helpful ideas. 

One possibility is that the man’s father was still alive, and “Let me bury my father” really meant, “Let me stay home and look after him until he passes away.” If that’s what he meant, Jesus might simply be saying no to an open-ended delay. Still, Luke never actually tells us the father was alive, so we can’t be sure.

Biblical scholar Byron McCane looks at a specific ancient Jewish custom where family members returned a year after a first burial to gather the bones and place them in a stone box, called an ossuary, inside the family tomb. If the man wanted to head back for that second burial, Jesus’s answer sounds like a sharp piece of wordplay: Let the dead already in the family tomb take care of the newly dead. It helps explain how the man could already be out on the road with Jesus while still having a burial duty left. But experts still debate how widely this custom was practiced.

Building on that same burial custom, scholar VănThanh Nguyễn (2025) points out that secondary burials were often tied to wealthy, high-status families showing off their standing. From that angle, Jesus could be pushing back against social prestige rather than basic family care. It’s an interesting thought, even though the story doesn’t tell us whether the man was rich or cared about status.

Scholar Markus Bockmuehl looks back to a specific practice in the Torah to answer this. In the Old Testament, God set apart high priests and Nazirites for special roles, and they could not touch a dead body, even when a close relative died. Bockmuehl suggests that Jesus’ words may echo the special dedication of a Nazirite, whose obligations could take precedence over family burial. He presents this as a possibility, not a settled explanation. In this view, Jesus upholds the Jewish law of attending to the burial of a family member rather than tossing it out. But Crispin Fletcher-Louis disagrees with this idea. He argues that Jesus is completely reshaping what counts as God’s family. 

There are other ways to hear the saying. Jesus may be using a deliberately shocking image to make the urgency of his call impossible to ignore. But even that does not answer every question. Why does He speak so sharply to a man asking to bury his father? What is it about this moment that cannot wait?

Jesus’s other teachings rule out a simple anti-family reading. In Mark 7:9-13, Jesus condemns people who use religious excuses to avoid caring for their parents. In John 19:26-27, while dying on the cross, Jesus arranges care for His own mother. These passages do not soften His words in Luke, but they stop us from turning his statement into a general command to neglect our families.

None of these explanations erases the tension, and we still do not know the man’s exact situation. Even so, Jesus gives a clear command: follow me and announce the Kingdom of God. The third man in the story also agrees to follow, yet asks to say goodbye to his family first. Adding that condition makes us wonder if he is truly serious about following Jesus.

After two thousand years, do we still feel that urgency? Today, we rarely treat the Kingdom of God like an immediate call to action. The message starts to sound routine, and we just carry on with our normal lives. Does the urgency of Jesus’s call still apply to our lives today?

Proclaiming the Kingdom means more than talking about Jesus. We make God’s reign visible by showing mercy, telling the truth, caring for overlooked people, and offering forgiveness.

What holds our attention? What claims our loyalty? What do we keep putting ahead of the life Jesus calls us to live?

Luke refuses to make that tension easy for us. Whether the man wanted an immediate burial, a long delay, or a later burial ritual, we cannot know for sure. What remains is Jesus’s sharp answer and his call to proclaim the Kingdom. We should not smooth over how hard his words sound, and we should not use them to guilt people for loving their families. Instead, we have to carry the question forward: How do we give God’s Kingdom our highest loyalty while still staying faithful to the people who rely on us?

Discussion questions

  1. Which explanation of Jesus’ words seems most plausible to you, and what remains troubling?
  2. In a distracted world, what might it mean to proclaim God’s Kingdom while caring for those entrusted to us?

David: I wonder whether Jesus might have been pointing to the fact that there are aspects of God we may never understand. We tend to think of Jesus as a teacher, an explainer. But in this class we’ve often found that he’s not so much an explainer as a provoker of thought about things of the Spirit.

In the passage Kiran has brought us this morning, could Jesus be acting rather as God did toward Job? Perhaps he’s saying, “There are things you’re simply never going to understand, and you need to understand that.” In other words, we need to recognize that there are things we will never understand.

Donald: It seems to me that, quite apart from this particular text, when we’re asked to share the gospel, we would usually understand sharing as caring. We wouldn’t separate the two. Caring is a way of sharing. I recognize that a distinction can be made according to the words being spoken, but care and love seem to be what Christ represents.

Loving your neighbor, your mother, and your father is part of the responsibility—indeed, it is the responsibility—of understanding who Christ is and what the Bible shares with us.

C-J: I think questioning is part of growth. We should always be questioning, not disrespectfully, but in a way that shows we’re processing what we’ve heard and seeking truth. Truth can look different depending on our position and perspective. I appreciated the point about the Nazirite restrictions on touching the dead.

Every culture has things that are forbidden because they are understood to protect the health of the community. I don’t think this was necessarily a question of righteousness or holiness. People might not have known what disease had taken someone’s life, and they wanted to protect those who paid their last respects up close. In Jewish traditions, women often took responsibility for washing and dressing the dead for interment. Such practices are found in many cultures, and they create a time to pause.

We can pause and still continue with life. I can wash dishes while crying for my mother. I can keep praying and mourning for a parent for years. But that experience also teaches me to use the time I have with those I love to love them well—not simply with a passing “I love you, dear, have a good day at school,” but with a deeper expression of love.

That’s part of the beauty of Jesus. He meets us where we are, on any given day and in any moment of loss or joy. That Spirit is universal, resident within us and throughout creation. I think this is a thread that motivates Jesus’ response, that Paul echoes, and that we also encounter in Job. God is doing a work that I don’t necessarily understand. It may be uncomfortable, but I believe God is always at work, and that work is deeply personal. We see examples of it throughout the Bible and other sacred writings.

Alyssa: Building on that, I’m struck by the relationship among trust, attachment, and sacrifice in this passage. It reminds me of a paper I wrote about Jesus’ temptation in the wilderness, particularly the account in Luke. I think that passage can also be read as Jesus giving us an example of how to live: balancing trust in God, self-sacrifice, and detachment from the world.

What troubles me in these passages is that the cost of being good, the cost of discipleship, the cost of trying to come as close as possible to Jesus’ character, seems to be suffering and sacrifice. That is very hard both to understand and to live through. Yet in this passage, as in the temptations, Jesus seems to want us to be able to accept that cost.

When the devil asks Jesus why he doesn’t turn the stones into bread and eat, I don’t think the question is really whether he has the power to do it. It’s about whether he can trust God. Will God allow him to starve? And if God does, can he accept that? Those are questions I ask myself every day. It’s very difficult to come to terms with this and find the right balance. How much of yourself can you give away in the pursuit of goodness?

Don: I’m wondering whether the key to understanding this difficult saying lies not so much in what Jesus forbids as in what he tells the men to do: proclaim the gospel of the kingdom. Many of you will remember Michael’s beautiful essay a few years ago about the gospel of the kingdom and the kingdom of heaven being synonymous with grace.

Perhaps Jesus is emphasizing that grace takes precedence over everything. Even the most honored and sacred traditions of a culture must be subordinate to grace. If that’s so, proclaiming the gift of grace must take precedence in everything we do, whether in life or in death.

C-J: I think Jesus’ experience in the wilderness also points to how we build resilience. It’s not simply a matter of saying, “I do believe, I do believe.” It’s a relationship of trust, and the question is how much you’re willing to endure. Over time, temptations become less likely to turn your head. You become more focused, more mission-driven, and more willing to do what it takes to reach the goal.

That clarity and willingness may come naturally to a few people, but I think most of us learn resilience by seeing it expressed in many different forms and ways of life. When we truly submit, we keep moving forward. It takes a long time to say, “I thought I saw God in one way, but I’ve been corrected. I now understand that God is in control, that this is in his hands, and that he’s teaching me something. It’s an opportunity, not simply a loss.”

Building that resilience, and learning which tool to use when we ask, “What would you have me do, Lord?”, is an extraordinary journey. We face pain, the loss of loved ones, and difficult decisions. I think the goal is resilience, with our eyes kept on God.

Reinhard: I see this account in both Matthew and Luke, and in Matthew the first person is described as a teacher of the law. Jesus tells him, “Foxes have holes and birds have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.” I think Jesus knows the hearts of those who genuinely want to commit their lives to following him and spreading the gospel.

There is also the saying that the fields are ripe for harvest. Jesus needed people to spread the gospel during that early period of his ministry. That gives a sense of urgency to these encounters. When he says, “Let the dead bury their dead,” I understand him as placing the preaching of the gospel ahead of even important personal and family obligations.

Today, we can see that kind of commitment in Sharon and other missionaries who go overseas. We should appreciate the difficulties they face in places where basic necessities are unavailable. Not everyone can go abroad as a missionary, of course. We still have Christian responsibilities in our own homes and cities, individually and as a community. But I think the main point is that God’s work must take priority over our personal duties.

We see Jesus’ mission in his encounters with Samaritans, outcasts, and the rich young ruler. These are all important lessons about spreading the gospel and eternal life. The need was urgent, and I think Jesus knew who was truly willing to commit. His different responses to the people in this passage may reflect that knowledge. Some people go overseas to serve, while others stay at home and do God’s work where they are. Why people receive different calls remains something of a mystery.

Michael: Perhaps this is influenced by the class I’ve been preparing, but I have a question: Can you love a dead person, or is love only for the living? Could that be part of the distinction Jesus is making? We think of paying our respects to the dead, but that is a human custom and tradition. I don’t know how God views the dead. There are biblical passages about our coming from the earth and returning to it, so I wonder whether something of that kind is happening here.

I’m also thinking about the Seventh-day Adventist understanding of death as sleep. I don’t know whether the original words carry that meaning. But perhaps Jesus is speaking about those who are spiritually asleep attending to someone who is physically dead, or asleep in death. In that sense, the people burying the dead may be those who have missed the meaning of Jesus’ message.

C-J: But Michael, both of my parents have died, and yet their DNA, their stories, their way of living, and the oral traditions of my family are still being carried forward. We all make decisions about how to respond to death. When one of my parents died, I decided to prepare the reception instead of being among the first people at the church for the service. My brother sent someone to find me. I was getting everything ready, because no one else had stayed to do it. They told me, “There are other people who could do this. You should be with us at the church.” But I couldn’t be there at that moment.

That’s something we humans do: we try to act responsibly. I knew my parents weren’t going to wake up and say good morning. I mourned them for a long time. But our relationship with God isn’t dependent on performing particular responsibilities here. God knows our hearts and the cultural conditions in which we live.

So yes, of course we love those who have died, even if we didn’t always like them. We love them, and we demonstrate that love in the ways we’ve been taught. Yet the greatest love is what God teaches us: to sacrifice, to think beyond today, and to bear witness to something beyond the immediate and concrete things that occupy us.

God is always saying, “Come to the mountain. Come to the top of the mountain and know who I am. Take off your shoes, for you stand on holy ground.” The Holy Spirit helps free us from those entanglements. The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak.

Michael: The difficulty is that someone who has died cannot experience or feel the love you’re giving them. Others may see it, but the person who died cannot.

C-J: I’m not expressing love because I want the person who died to see how much I loved them, or because I want other people to see my tears and say, “Look how deeply she loved them.” Love isn’t about what shows on the outside. It’s about what we commit to with God, inwardly. Love transforms us.

We might decide, “I won’t treat another person that way again. I want to do better at expressing love.” I don’t want people simply to see my love, which is inadequate. I want them to see what Jesus’ love can do for others—the broken, the disenfranchised, the tired, and those who give their last penny. That’s what matters, Michael. It’s not the individual gesture, or precisely how and when it is expressed, but the intention behind it. There are people I haven’t seen in twenty years whom I still love and hold in my heart.

Donald: What would sharing the gospel look like if it weren’t done in a spirit of love, care, and kindness? I think it would be rather hollow. You can attend a lecture and learn something, but if a person demonstrates those qualities while sharing the gospel, the message becomes far more meaningful.

I’m not suggesting that this solves the problem of the passage. Kiran mentioned the duty to bury a loved one. I hope burying someone we love is not simply a duty, although I recognize that cultures respond differently to death. If we regard it only as a duty, we may take some of the caring emotion out of it and see it merely as our turn to fulfill a responsibility. But when it’s done in love for the person who has died, and for the family and friends who are grieving, that is extraordinarily important.

C-J: But isn’t love at the root of duty?

Donald: I agree that it can be. But to me, the word “duty” can suggest doing something because it’s my turn or my responsibility, with some of the loving emotion removed. Think of Mother Teresa. Her work demonstrated an extraordinary degree of care, love, and kindness as an expression of her faith. For her, sharing faith and caring for people were one and the same. That’s the point I’m trying to make.

David: It’s interesting that Mother Teresa herself had profound doubts, despite all she did. I don’t think we’re any closer to answering Kiran’s questions, and I’m not sure we ever could be. There’s no question that we’re enjoined to love. But much evangelism, in my view, is practiced not so much through love as through zealotry and other motivations that lead people to spread the gospel.

I cannot imagine Jesus urging his disciples to be zealous at the expense of love. That would not be consistent with the Jesus I understand. And for the life of me, I cannot understand this passage that Kiran has presented to us. I really can’t. So perhaps I have to accept that I may never understand it, and with that, accept that there are aspects of God I will never understand.

C-J: Isn’t the bottom line to do what you do with love? Suppose you choose to go and bury the dead while Jesus is saying that the hour is near and we must be vigilant so as many people as possible can hear the message. Paul echoes that urgency at times. But we’re human. We see through the lenses of our own experience and understanding as we look at others and listen to them.

If someone said to Jesus, “I know you want me with you, but I have this duty. It isn’t that I’m choosing my family over you. Other people need me to demonstrate the love you’re teaching, and I will return,” wouldn’t that also be an example of his message? Honor your mother and father. Be there for your family. Be a witness in your community so that nobody can point to your conduct and say that you failed to care.

We cannot manufacture that love; it is something God gives us. At least, that’s how I understand it when I experience it in my own life or recognize it in another person. These decisions are very difficult, and the older we become, the more often we have to make them.

Sharon: I’m rather with David on this one. But I’m fascinated by Jesus’ use of hyperbole. I teach, too, and sometimes I use quite radical statements that may not make immediate sense. I would love to know who Jesus’ audience was in this particular encounter. He was speaking to one man, of course, but he often used an individual’s experience to teach the disciples and others who were present.

I look forward to asking Jesus in heaven what he meant. We can speculate, but I don’t think we can necessarily understand it completely. He frequently used hyperbole—shocking statements—to command people’s attention. I think there’s an underlying message here about the urgency of living wholly in grace, with complete commitment, because that brings peace, focus, and direction to our lives instead of allowing worldly concerns to scatter and distract us.

It’s Jesus’ method of teaching that interests me so much. We know he expected people to care for and bury their family members. We need to start with that assumption, unless this was a secondary burial a year later, as Kiran described, which might have made the request something different. Still, I’m struck by how Jesus could unsettle people who were not easily unsettled, simply by saying something startling. And here we are, thousands of years later, in a Sabbath school class, still pondering what he meant by such an outlandish statement.

I look forward to finding out who was listening and what the central point was. Until then, I can live at peace with the conviction that I should devote myself as fully as I can to a life of grace and service, and try to make the world a little better while I have the opportunity.

David: There’s another possible explanation we haven’t really considered: the Gospel accounts may simply be incomplete. Perhaps the people who recorded the event didn’t include enough of the surrounding conversation or circumstances for us to understand it. That seems a genuine possibility to me.

I don’t know precisely what it means for Seventh-day Adventists to believe that the Bible is God’s Word. Does that belief require that the Bible is complete, that nothing relevant is missing from the record? If so, I’m back to my earlier thought: there are things we simply may never understand.

C-J: I think you’re right that these were oral traditions, passed down and then written, selected, and compiled. But when you look at ancient sacred writings more generally, you find common themes: love, grace, forgiveness, obligations to family, and how to live amid political unrest or imperfect religious hierarchies. There are what Donald calls “guardrails” that tell us when we’ve gone off the track.

I think these are universal truths, written in our hearts. We often recognize right and wrong intuitively by the reactions we see. Grace creates calm, while self-defense can create a war of “I’m right and you’re wrong.” These stories call us to commitment, resilience, discernment, and preparation for a future beyond the here and now.

Perhaps the stories are unfinished because we are still participating in the unfolding of our faith and how we live it. If we surrender to God’s will, we give God a better chance to become visible in our behavior and choices, including how we acknowledge our mistakes and how we respond to another person’s pain rather than simply pursuing our own agenda. I think the incompleteness may be intentional. The lives of those who passed down these accounts were short and difficult.

Don: A simple way of understanding Jesus might be that whatever we’re doing in life—even the things we do around death—should be governed by the gospel of grace. If we keep that in mind, we’re following him.

Reinhard: I agree that following Jesus is the most important thing. I also liked Sharon’s point about hyperbole. Jesus used it on other occasions, such as when he spoke of plucking out an eye or cutting off a hand rather than allowing it to lead us into sin. He said it was better to enter heaven maimed than to lose one’s life with the body intact. These are striking examples of language not meant to be taken literally.

Returning to “Let the dead bury their dead,” I think the first “dead” can mean those who are spiritually dead, who have not received God’s message, while the second refers to people who have died physically. We also have to remember that, under Old Testament law, contact with a dead body made someone ceremonially unclean, requiring purification.I believe the purification took seven days before the person was considered clean and could return to worship. In that context, I can see why Jesus might have emphasized urgency. There was no time to delay. Following him and spreading the gospel were crucial because the fields were ripe and many people needed to hear the message.

The Bible also says, “Many are called, but few are chosen.” It’s interesting that Jesus did not invite the first person in the same way; instead, he warned him that the Son of Man had nowhere to lay his head. Perhaps there is a selection involved in who is called to a particular work. Not everybody who wishes to serve God will be called to the same role, and that can remain a mystery to us.

Jesus made other statements that his listeners found difficult. For example, when he said that his flesh was real food, many disciples left him. Following Jesus is not easy; it requires sacrifice. But by God’s grace we look forward to eternal life and the crown he promises us. That is important for Christians to remember.

David raised a question about Seventh-day Adventists. I would add that I regard the writings of Ellen White as giving Adventists additional understanding intended to strengthen our faith and bring us closer to God. I recently saw a social media report about weekly religious-service attendance. If I remember it correctly, Seventh-day Adventists were ranked first, at about 75 percent, followed by Mormons and Orthodox Jews. I think that was probably a U.S. survey. In countries such as Indonesia, I believe Adventist Sabbath attendance may be even higher, perhaps around 90 percent. I see that as an encouraging sign of commitment to the teachings we’ve received. I hope we can find peace in what we’ve discussed today.

Kiran: Listening to all of you has brought two things to mind. In many passages Jesus says that the kingdom of God is here and invites people to receive it. There’s urgency in that invitation. But in this particular case, the man is already with Jesus. We might assume he has accepted the kingdom in his heart. Now Jesus tells him that he must urgently go and tell someone else.

Perhaps the urgency concerns the people to whom Jesus is sending him. Maybe there’s a town where people need to hear this message, and Jesus is thinking of what might happen to them if they don’t receive it. So there may be two kinds of urgency. Outside Jesus’ community, the urgency is to receive the message. Once you’re within it, the urgency is to share it with others.

That brings me back to Dr. Weaver’s point about grace. If we’ve received God’s grace, simply sitting on it and keeping it to ourselves can become toxic. We know how much receiving the kingdom has helped us; we should recognize how valuable it might be to someone else. Perhaps that’s the urgency Jesus is pointing to here. I don’t know whether that helps us understand the passage, but it occurred to me as I listened.

Don: Very provocative material, Kiran, and a fine series on the puzzling sayings of Jesus. I think Sharon and David both made good points: some of these sayings are difficult to sort out. Jesus certainly used hyperbole. And people have, over the centuries, taken some of his hyperbolic statements literally. As Reinhard pointed out, there have been people who put out their eyes or cut off their hands because they mistook such language for a literal command.

Any final thoughts? If not, we’ll look forward to more of these studies. Michael will also be contributing some essays, interspersed with those David is working on. We have much to be thankful for, and much to anticipate as we continue studying God’s Word.

* * *

Leave a Reply